The Challenge All Stars 2 Cast Details & Insights

NovaRogue
9 min readOct 13, 2021

Departure for All Stars 3 is this week yet they still haven’t officially announced All Stars 2. So here’s an article detailing the 24 alumni who filmed AS2.

Hopefully it reaches the heights of RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars 2, but the cast is nowhere near that caliber. So… 🤞🏼 for All Stars 3?

No spoilers for All Stars 2 or Spies, Lies, & Allies in this article 😇

Cast

Women

Casey Cooper

Last appearance: The Ruins (2009)

Previous seasons: 4

Highest finish: 3rd place on Fresh Meat I

Original show: Fresh Meat I (2006)

Finals & wins: 1 & 0

Daily wins: 11

Elim record: 5–3

Note: alternate for All Stars 1, holds the record for most eliminations won on a single season (5, tied with Wes and Sarah Greyson)

Jasmine Fougere (née Reynaud)

Last appearance: Free Agents (2014)

Previous seasons: 5

Highest finish: 4th place on Rivals I

Original show: Real World Cancun (2009)

Finals & wins: 0 & 0

Daily wins: 5

Elim record: 1–5

Janelle Rose (née Casanave)

Last appearance: Gauntlet III (2008)

Previous seasons: 2

Highest finish: winner on Inferno 3

Original show: Real World Key West (2006)

Finals & wins: 1 & 1

Daily wins: 10

Elim record: 0–1

Jodi Weatherton

Last appearance: The Duel I (2007)

Previous seasons: 3

Highest finish: winner on Gauntlet 2 & Duel I

Original show: Road Rules X-Treme (2004)

Finals & wins: 2 & 2

Daily wins: 19

Elim record: 0–1

Jonna Stephens (née Manion)

Last appearance: All Stars 1 (2021)

Previous seasons: 5 + 1 spin-off

Highest finish: 1st for women and 3rd overall on All Stars 1

Original show: Real World Cancun (2009)

Finals & wins: 0 & 0 canon, 1 spin-off final

Daily wins: 6 + 1 spin-off

Elim record: 2–5

Katie Cooley (née Doyle)

Last appearance: All Stars 1 (2021)

Previous seasons: 9 + 1 spin-off

Highest finish: winner on Inferno I

Original show: Road Rules The Quest (2001)

Finals & wins: 1 & 1

Daily wins: 36

Elim record: 4–6

Kendal Darnell (née Sheppard)

Last appearance: All Stars 1 (2021)

Previous seasons: 1 + 1 spin-off

Highest finish: winner on Inferno I

Original show: Road Rules Campus Crawl (2002)

Finals & wins: 1 & 1

Daily wins: 11 + 3 spin-off

Elim record: 1–0 & 2–1 on spin-offs

Leah Gillingwater

Last appearance: The Inferno I (2004)

Previous seasons: 1

Highest finish: lost penultimate elimination on Inferno I

Original show: Real World Paris (2003)

Finals & wins: 0 & 0

Daily wins: 4

Elim record: 0–1

Melinda Stolp

Last appearance: Battle of the Seasons (2012)

Previous seasons: 4

Highest finish: lost third-last elimination on Gauntlet III

Original show: Real World Austin (2005)

Finals & wins: 0 & 0

Daily wins: 4

Elim record: 0–4

Note: holds the record for most seasons without winning an elimination

Tina Barta

Last appearance: Heavy Hitter on Cutthroat (2010) / The Duel I (2007)

Previous seasons: 5

Highest finish: second place on Fresh Meat I

Original show: Road Rules South Pacific (2003)

Finals & wins: 2 & 0

Daily wins: 15

Elim record: 3–1

Sophia Pasquis

Last appearance: Battle of the Sexes 2 (2005)

Previous seasons: 1

Highest finish: finalist on Battle of the Sexes 2

Original show: Road Rules The Quest (2001)

Finals & wins: 1 & 0

Daily wins: 3

Elim record: 0–0

Ayanna Mackins

Last appearance: Battle of the Sexes 2 (2005)

Previous seasons: 3

Highest finish: Top 8 on Battle of the Sexes 2

Original show: Road Rules Semester at Sea (1999)

Finals & wins: 0 & 0

Daily wins: 6

Elim record: 0–0

Note: slept in her uniform because she wanted to win today

Men

Brad Fiorenza

Last appearance: Final Reckoning (2018)

Previous seasons: 10

Highest finish: winner on Cutthroat

Original show: Real World San Diego (2004)

Finals & wins: 4 & 1

Daily wins: 41

Elim record: 6–6

Cohutta Grindstaff

Last appearance: Battle of the Bloodlines (2016)

Previous seasons: 4

Highest finish: 6th place on Free Agents

Original show: Real Word Sydney

Finals & wins: 0 & 0

Daily wins: 4

Elim record: 3–4

Note: alternate for All Stars 1

Darrell Taylor

Last appearance: All Stars 1 (2021)

Previous seasons: 9 + 3 spin-offs

Highest finish: winner on The Gauntlet I, The Inferno I, The Inferno II, Fresh Meat I, and Champs vs Pros

Original show: Road Rules Campus Crawl (2002)

Finals & wins: 4 & 4 and 2 & 1 on spin-offs

Daily wins: 38 + 6 spin-off

Elim record: 6–3

Note: holds the record for most seasons won consecutively (4)

Derek Chavez

Last appearance: Rivals II (2013)

Previous seasons: 3

Highest finish: 4th place on Battle of the Seasons II

Original show: Real World Cancun (2009)

Finals & wins: 0 & 0

Daily wins: 2

Elim record: 1–3

Derrick Kosinski

Last appearance: All Stars 1 (2021)

Previous seasons: 10 + 1 spin-off

Highest finish: winner on The Inferno 3, The Island, & The Ruins

Original show: Road Rules X-Treme (2004)

Finals & wins: 5 & 3 and 1 & 0 on spin-offs

Daily wins: 43 + 1 spin-off

Elim record: 9–5

Laterrian Wallace

Last appearance: All Stars 1 (2021)

Previous seasons: 3 + 1 spin-off

Highest finish: finalist on Extreme Challenge / lost fourth last elimination on The Gauntlet I

Original show: Road Rules Maximum Velocity Tour (2000)

Finals & wins: 1 & 0

Daily wins: 13 + 2 spin-off

Elim record: 0–1 and 1–1 spin-off

MJ Garrett

Last appearance: The Duel II (2009)

Previous seasons: 3

Highest finish: winner on Gauntlet 2

Original show: Real World Philadelphia (2005)

Finals & wins: 1 & 1

Daily wins: 10

Elim record: 2–2

Nehemiah Clark

Last appearance: All Stars 1 (2021)

Previous seasons: 4 + 1 spin-off

Highest finish: winner on Gauntlet III

Original show: Real World Austin (2005)

Finals & wins: 1 & 1

Daily wins: 5 + 2 spin-off

Elim record: 3–3 and 1–1 spin-off

Ryan Kehoe

Last appearance: Fresh Meat II (2010)

Previous seasons: 5

Highest finish: finalist on The Island

Original show: Fresh Meat I (2006)

Finals & wins: 1 & 0

Daily wins: 3

Elim record: 3–4

Note: alternate for All Stars 1

Steve Meinke

Last appearance: The Gauntlet I (2004)

Previous seasons: 1

Highest finish: lost seventh-last elimination Gauntlet I

Original show: Road Rules The Quest (2001)

Finals & wins: 0 & 0

Daily wins: 6

Elim record: 1–1

Teck Holmes

Last appearance: All Stars 1 (2021)

Previous seasons: 1 + 1 spin-off

Highest finish: finalist on Challenge 2000

Original show: Real World Hawaii (1999)

Finals & wins: 1 & 0

Daily wins: 3 + 1 spin-off

Elim record: 0–0 and 0–1 spin-off

Tyler Duckworth

Last appearance: Rivals I (2011)

Previous seasons: 4

Highest finish: winner on Cutthroat & Rivals I

Original show: Real World Key West (2006)

Finals & wins: 2 & 2

Daily wins: 5

Elim record: 4–2

.

Alternates

Jemmye Carroll & Emilee Fitzpatrick

Syrus Yarbrough & Brandon Nelson

.

Sequestered but didn’t make it to location

Svetlana Shusterman & Ruthie Alcaide

Replaced last-minute

Shauvon Torres (replaced by Tina)

--

--

NovaRogue

I write about MTV’s The Challenge, with a queer / social justice / critical analysis bent. #UnspoiledGang